Ronald Reagan · the Rose Garden · November 2, 1983
text: The American Presidency Project, UC Santa Barbara · a work of the United States government, in the public domain
colour carries the act's function; a dashed underline marks a predicted misfire; hover or focus any span for its filing
The President. Mrs. King, members of the King family, distinguished Members of the Congress, ladies and gentlemen, honored guests, I'm very pleased to welcome you to the White House,Declaration — Bring a state into being by saying so. function: declaration · orientation: reality · motive: cooperative · scope: narrow · target: outwarda welcome takes effect in the saying, and it is the one state on this page the speaker's words bring about; the state everyone came for is brought about by a pen, offstage, at the endthe home that belongs to all of us, the American people.Frame-set — Install the construal that fixes which moves are legal. function: declaration · orientation: belonging · motive: mixed · scope: wide · target: metathe appositive reassigns the house before the guests are inside it: the King family is received by a building rather than admitted by its occupant, which removes the question of who is hosting whom
When I was thinking of the contributions to our country of the man that we're honoring today, a passage attributed to the American poet John Greenleaf Whittier comes to mind. "Each crisis brings its word and deed."Report — Relay another's utterance. function: assertive · orientation: reality · motive: cooperative · scope: wide · target: metathe first words quoted at a ceremony for an orator belong to a nineteenth-century New England abolitionist poet, and their authorship is hedged — "attributed to"; the schema they supply governs the next four paragraphsIn America, in the fifties and sixties, one of the important crises we faced was racial discrimination.Frame-set — Install the construal that fixes which moves are legal. function: declaration · orientation: reality · motive: mixed · scope: wide · target: metaWhittier's crisis is filled in: discrimination is a period ("the fifties and sixties"), an item in a series ("one of the important crises"), and something "we faced" together; each of the three settles a question the rest of the speech never reopensThe man whose words and deeds in that crisis stirred our nation to the very depths of its soul was Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr.Assertion — State that something is the case. function: assertive · orientation: reality · motive: cooperative · scope: wide · target: outwardthe grammar makes King what the crisis produced — its word and its deed — rather than a man who chose a side against opposition the sentence does not mention
Martin Luther King was born in 1929 in an America where, because of the color of their skin, nearly 1 in 10 lived lives that were separate and unequal.Assertion — State that something is the case. function: assertive · orientation: reality · motive: cooperative · scope: wide · target: outwardMost black Americans were taught in segregated schools. Across the country, too many could find only poor jobs, toiling for low wages. They were refused entry into hotels and restaurants, made to use separate facilities.Assertion — State that something is the case. function: assertive · orientation: reality · motive: cooperative · scope: wide · target: outward"were taught," "were refused," "made to use" — three passives and no agent; the injuries have victims and no authors, and the speech supplies an author for none of them until the assassin arrives five paragraphs laterIn a nation that proclaimed liberty and justice for all, too many black Americans were living with neither.Assertion — State that something is the case. function: assertive · orientation: reality · motive: cooperative · scope: wide · target: outward
In one city, a rule required all blacks to sit in the rear of public buses.Assertion — State that something is the case. function: assertive · orientation: reality · motive: cooperative · scope: narrow · target: outwardMontgomery is not named, and the instrument is "a rule" rather than a city ordinance and a state code; the sentence localises to one city a practice the previous paragraph placed "across the country"But in 1955, when a brave woman named Rosa Parks was told to move to the back of the bus, she said, "No."Report — Relay another's utterance. function: assertive · orientation: reality · motive: cooperative · scope: narrow · target: metaa one-word quotation, and the only utterance in the speech reported from someone who was not being honored; "was told" keeps the agent out even hereA young minister in a local Baptist church, Martin Luther King, then organized a boycott of the bus company—a boycott that stunned the country.Assertion — State that something is the case. function: assertive · orientation: reality · motive: cooperative · scope: narrow · target: outwardWithin 6 months the courts had ruled the segregation of public transportation unconstitutional.Assertion — State that something is the case. function: assertive · orientation: reality · motive: cooperative · scope: narrow · target: outwardthe clock given is the court's; the boycott ran 381 days, and the episode is closed here by a ruling rather than by the people who kept walking through the winter after it
Dr. King had awakened something strong and true, a sense that true justice must be colorblind,Frame-set — Install the construal that fixes which moves are legal. function: declaration · orientation: reality · motive: mixed · scope: wide · target: metamisfire: frame collision — the awakening's content is stated in a word that appears nowhere in the sentence brought in to support it, and the borrowed sentence says destinies are tied and freedoms bound, which is a claim about what two peoples owe each other rather than about what may be noticedand that among white and black Americans, as he put it, "Their destiny is tied up with our destiny, and their freedom is inextricably bound to our freedom; we cannot walk alone."Report — Relay another's utterance. function: assertive · orientation: reality · motive: cooperative · scope: wide · target: metaat the Lincoln Memorial the possessives had owners: King was addressing black listeners about the white marchers who had come, and "our" was the movement's; the prefix "among white and black Americans" makes the sentence symmetrical and leaves the pronouns unassigned
In the years after the bus boycott, Dr. King made equality of rights his life's work. Across the country, he organized boycotts, rallies, and marches.Assertion — State that something is the case. function: assertive · orientation: reality · motive: cooperative · scope: wide · target: outwardOften he was beaten, imprisoned, but he never stopped teaching nonviolence.Assertion — State that something is the case. function: assertive · orientation: reality · motive: cooperative · scope: wide · target: outwardthe passive returns for the beatings and the jailings; nonviolence is filed as a doctrine he taught rather than as the method he used against the people doing them"Work with the faith", he told his followers, "that unearned suffering is redemptive."Report — Relay another's utterance. function: assertive · orientation: reality · motive: cooperative · scope: wide · target: metathe second King quotation, and its addressee is specified — "his followers"; a lesson given to a movement is entered here as a lesson given to the countryIn 1964 Dr. King became the youngest man in history to win the Nobel Peace Prize.Assertion — State that something is the case. function: assertive · orientation: reality · motive: cooperative · scope: narrow · target: outward
Dr. King's work brought him to this city often. And in one sweltering August day in 1963, he addressed a quarter of a million people at the Lincoln Memorial.Assertion — State that something is the case. function: assertive · orientation: reality · motive: cooperative · scope: narrow · target: outwardthe March on Washington for Jobs and Freedom enters as weather, a crowd count, and a monument; its name, its organizers, and its ten demands are absent, and so is the President who tried to have it called offIf American history grows from two centuries to twenty, his words that day will never be forgotten.Assertion — State that something is the case. function: assertive · orientation: reality · motive: cooperative · scope: wide · target: outward"I have a dream that one day on the red hills of Georgia, the sons of former slaves and the sons of former slave owners will be able to sit down together at the table of brotherhood."Report — Relay another's utterance. function: assertive · orientation: reality · motive: cooperative · scope: wide · target: metathe quotation is exact and it is a choice: the same address opens with a check returned marked "insufficient funds" and a demand for payment, and the stanza selected here is the one in which nobody is asked for anything
In 1968 Martin Luther King was gunned down by a brutal assassin, his life cut short at the age of 39.Assertion — State that something is the case. function: assertive · orientation: reality · motive: cooperative · scope: narrow · target: outwardthe first named agent in the speech's account of American racial injury is one man, and he is the only party in it given a moral adjective; the schools, the hotels, the jails, and the rule about the rear of the bus were all reported without a subjectBut those 39 short years had changed America forever.Assertion — State that something is the case. function: assertive · orientation: reality · motive: cooperative · scope: wide · target: outwardThe Civil Rights Act of 1964 had guaranteed all Americans equal use of public accommodations, equal access to programs financed by Federal funds,Assertion — State that something is the case. function: assertive · orientation: reality · motive: cooperative · scope: wide · target: outwardthe two clauses track the statute's own titles closely enough to read as citation, which is what lends the third clause its air of citationand the right to compete for employment on the sole basis of individual merit.Frame-set — Install the construal that fixes which moves are legal. function: declaration · orientation: reality · motive: mixed · scope: wide · target: metamisfire: frame collision — the phrase "sole basis of individual merit" is in no title of the 1964 Act, and it arrives in the grammar of the two paraphrases beside it; a contested standard for what compliance requires is entered as though it were being quoted (low confidence)The Voting Rights Act of 1965 had made certain that from then on black Americans would get to vote.Assertion — State that something is the case. function: assertive · orientation: reality · motive: cooperative · scope: wide · target: outwardmisfire: scope mismatch — read narrow, a summary of what the Act did; read wide, "from then on" and the past perfect close the file on enforcement, and the Act's special provisions had needed renewing the year before this ceremony (low confidence)But most important, there was not just a change of law; there was a change of heart.Frame-set — Install the construal that fixes which moves are legal. function: declaration · orientation: reality · motive: mixed · scope: wide · target: metamisfire: frame collision — the ranking puts the decisive remedy where no statute can reach it, and every instrument the speech goes on to prescribe is scaled to that ruling: remembrance, rededication, two commandmentsThe conscience of America had been touched.Assertion — State that something is the case. function: assertive · orientation: reality · motive: cooperative · scope: wide · target: outwardAcross the land, people had begun to treat each other not as blacks and whites, but as fellow Americans.Assertion — State that something is the case. function: assertive · orientation: belonging · motive: cooperative · scope: wide · target: outwardmisfire: orientation mismatch — a claim about how a country's people behave toward one another, offered without instance or measure, in a speech that concedes two paragraphs later that bigotry still mars America; what it delivers is standing rather than a finding (low confidence)
And since Dr. King's death, his father, the Reverend Martin Luther King, Sr., and his wife, Coretta King, have eloquently and forcefully carried on his work.Assertion — State that something is the case. function: assertive · orientation: reality · motive: cooperative · scope: narrow · target: outwardthe woman who ran the fifteen-year campaign for this bill is credited with continuing her husband's work; the bill itself is credited, in the next sentence but one, to "our nation"Also his family have joined in that cause.Assertion — State that something is the case. function: assertive · orientation: reality · motive: cooperative · scope: narrow · target: outward
Now our nation has decided to honor Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr., by setting aside a day each year to remember him and the just cause he stood for.Assertion — State that something is the case. function: assertive · orientation: reality · motive: cooperative · scope: wide · target: outwardthe deciding party is "our nation"; the House vote, the Senate vote, the filibuster, the petitions, and the speaker's own position on the bill are all outside the sentence that reports how the day came to existWe've made historic strides since Rosa Parks refused to go to the back of the bus.Assertion — State that something is the case. function: assertive · orientation: belonging · motive: cooperative · scope: wide · target: outwardAs a democratic people, we can take pride in the knowledge that we Americans recognized a grave injustice and took action to correct it.Assertion — State that something is the case. function: assertive · orientation: belonging · motive: cooperative · scope: wide · target: outward"we Americans" is the subject of the recognition and of the correction; the injustice was given four paragraphs earlier with no subject at all, and that vacancy is what leaves the first person free to collect the creditAnd we should remember that in far too many countries, people like Dr. King never have the opportunity to speak out at all.Order — Direct another to act. function: directive · orientation: belonging · motive: mixed · scope: wide · target: outwardmisfire: orientation mismatch — the comparison is refuted by the speech's own record four paragraphs up, "Often he was beaten, imprisoned"; the standard is moved abroad, and what the sentence secures is the nation's rank rather than a fact about the man being honored
But traces of bigotry still mar America.Assertion — State that something is the case. function: assertive · orientation: reality · motive: cooperative · scope: wide · target: outwardthe noun is "traces" and the verb is "mar" — surface damage to a finished thing; this is the whole of what the speech says is left, and it sets the size of the remedy proposed in the next sentenceSo, each year on Martin Luther King Day, let us not only recall Dr. King, but rededicate ourselves to the Commandments he believed in and sought to live every day:Order — Direct another to act. function: directive · orientation: belonging · motive: cooperative · scope: wide · target: outwardthe hortative names the day's assignment, and it assigns it to everyone equally; no party, office, agency, or employer is separately addressed anywhere in these remarksThou shall love thy God with all thy heart, and thou shall love thy neighbor as thyself.Report — Relay another's utterance. function: assertive · orientation: reality · motive: cooperative · scope: wide · target: metathe content of the rededication, and neither commandment can be discharged by a vote, a court, a contract, or an appropriation; the man being honored had made all four of those his instrumentsAnd I just have to believe that all of us—if all of us, young and old, Republicans and Democrats, do all we can to live up to those Commandments, then we will see the day when Dr. King's dream comes true,Assertion — State that something is the case. function: assertive · orientation: belonging · motive: cooperative · scope: wide · target: outwardthe condition placed on the dream is private observance by everyone, and the pairing that stands where "blacks and whites" stood earlier is "Republicans and Democrats" — the division the objectors in the room belong toand in his words, "All of God's children will be able to sing with new meaning, '... land where my fathers died, land of the pilgrim's pride, from every mountainside, let freedom ring.'"Report — Relay another's utterance. function: assertive · orientation: reality · motive: cooperative · scope: wide · target: metathe ellipsis is in the transcript, and the peroration stops before King's list of the places freedom must ring from — Stone Mountain, Lookout Mountain, every hill and molehill of Mississippi — and before "Free at last"
Thank you,Thanks — Express gratitude. function: expressive · orientation: reality · motive: cooperative · scope: narrow · target: outward God bless you, and I will sign it.Declaration — Bring a state into being by saying so. function: declaration · orientation: reality · motive: cooperative · scope: narrow · target: outwardfour words, and they are the whole of the remarks' contact with the bill; the act they announce is performed by a hand a moment later, which is why the declaration on this page stands where a performative would and does not perform
Mrs. King. Thank you, Mr. President, Vice President Bush, Majority Leader Baker and the distinguished congressional and senatorial delegations, and other representatives who've gathered here, and friends.Thanks — Express gratitude. function: expressive · orientation: belonging · motive: cooperative · scope: wide · target: outwardthe order of the list is the order of the room's official standing; the organizers, churches, and unions that carried the petitions are gathered into "friends" at the end
All right-thinking people, all right-thinking Americans are joined in spirit with us this dayFrame-set — Install the construal that fixes which moves are legal. function: declaration · orientation: belonging · motive: mixed · scope: wide · target: metamisfire: frame collision — the frame makes assent to the day a test of judgment, which presumes a country still holding out; the remarks that preceded these from the same lectern described a country whose conscience had already been touched, with nobody left to convert (low confidence)as the highest recognition which this nation gives is bestowed upon Martin Luther King, Jr., one who also was the recipient of the highest recognition which the world bestows, the Nobel Peace Prize.Assertion — State that something is the case. function: assertive · orientation: belonging · motive: cooperative · scope: wide · target: outward"is bestowed" keeps the bestower out of the sentence, and the national honor is set beside one the world gave nineteen years earlier; the pairing dates the country's recognition rather than celebrating it
In his own life's example, he symbolized what was right about America, what was noblest and best, what human beings have pursued since the beginning of history.Assertion — State that something is the case. function: assertive · orientation: belonging · motive: cooperative · scope: wide · target: outwardHe loved unconditionally. He was in constant pursuit of truth, and when he discovered it, he embraced it.Assertion — State that something is the case. function: assertive · orientation: reality · motive: cooperative · scope: narrow · target: outwardHis nonviolent campaigns brought about redemption, reconciliation, and justice.Assertion — State that something is the case. function: assertive · orientation: reality · motive: cooperative · scope: wide · target: outwardthe campaigns are the subject and justice is what they produced; the remarks from the other lectern gave the same result to courts and to statutes, and gave the campaigns the verb "organized"He taught us that only peaceful means can bring about peaceful ends, that our goal was to create the love community.Report — Relay another's utterance. function: assertive · orientation: reality · motive: cooperative · scope: wide · target: metathe fourth relay of King's teaching on this page and the first with "us" as the taught; the President's version had specified "his followers"
America is a more democratic nation, a more just nation, a more peaceful nation because Martin Luther King, Jr., became her preeminent nonviolent commander.Assertion — State that something is the case. function: assertive · orientation: belonging · motive: cooperative · scope: wide · target: outward"commander" restores rank and command to a man the earlier remarks introduced as "a young minister in a local Baptist church," and the improvement in the country is made consequent on him rather than on a change of heart it underwent
Martin Luther King, Jr., and his spirit live within all of us.Assertion — State that something is the case. function: assertive · orientation: belonging · motive: cooperative · scope: wide · target: outwardThank God for the blessing of his life and his leadership and his commitment.Thanks — Express gratitude. function: expressive · orientation: reality · motive: cooperative · scope: narrow · target: outwardWhat manner of man was this?Rhetorical question — Ask in form, assert in force. function: directive · orientation: belonging · motive: mixed · scope: wide · target: outwardthe answer has been given in the four preceding sentences, and the question is put to a room that has just been told which people are joined in spirit with itMay we make ourselves worthy to carry on his dream and create the love community.Order — Direct another to act. function: directive · orientation: belonging · motive: cooperative · scope: wide · target: outwardthe hortative assigns unfinished work — "carry on," "create" — where the President's hortative assigned recall and rededication to something already believedThank you.Thanks — Express gratitude. function: expressive · orientation: reality · motive: cooperative · scope: narrow · target: outward
The divergences
"Dr. King had awakened something strong and true, a sense that true justice must be colorblind" — the White House files an Assertion about what the bus boycott taught the country; the civil rights lawyers who had seen the Court reject this administration's position in Bob Jones five months earlier file a Frame-set, after which a remedy that counts by race is the injustice and the people opposing such remedies are King's heirs. They part on function. The test sits inside the same sentence: the quotation brought in to support the awakening says that destinies are tied and freedoms bound together, which is a claim about what two peoples owe each other. The day is given its meaning here, six paragraphs before the pen.
"Their destiny is tied up with our destiny, and their freedom is inextricably bound to our freedom; we cannot walk alone" — at the Lincoln Memorial the possessives had owners. King was warning black listeners against distrust of all white people, because many of "our white brothers, as evidenced by their presence here today," had come to see their freedom bound to the movement's. Relayed behind the phrase "among white and black Americans," the pronouns lose their assignment and the sentence becomes a symmetry between two equal parties. The ceremony files a Report; a listener who can place the sentence files a move on the quotation rather than on the world. They part on target. What follows in King is the pledge the borrowed half was building toward: "we shall always march ahead. We cannot turn back."
"I have a dream that one day on the red hills of Georgia, the sons of former slaves and the sons of former slave owners will be able to sit down together at the table of brotherhood" — the quotation is accurate and it is a selection. The same address arraigns the country for a check returned marked "insufficient funds" and demands payment; it names a Mississippi "sweltering with the heat of injustice" and "the unspeakable horrors of police brutality." The ceremony files a Report of the most famous sentence in American oratory; an audience that can supply the rest of the address files the choice of stanza. They part on motive — whether the passage quoted is the passage or the passage that asks nobody for anything. The holiday takes its name from the dream and enters the record without the bill of exchange.
"But most important, there was not just a change of law; there was a change of heart" — read narrow, a claim about what the 1960s produced, and defensible. Read wide, a ranking that places the decisive remedy where no statute reaches, which makes a day of remembrance the instrument that fits the problem. They part on scope. Everything prescribed after this sentence is remembrance, rededication, and two commandments, and the sentence is the point at which the law stops being the subject under discussion.
"The Voting Rights Act of 1965 had made certain that from then on black Americans would get to vote" — the archive's Johnson page files the same statute with its machinery attached: examiners at work "by Tuesday morning" in 10 to 15 counties, poll tax suits in three named States, and a pledge that "we will not delay, or we will not hesitate, or we will not turn aside." Here the Act is entered in the past perfect with "from then on," a guarantee already delivered — sixteen months after the same administration had contested the terms of its renewal. They part on orientation: keyed to a statute somebody has to enforce, or to a country's account of itself as finished. The two ceremonies are the archive's cleanest pen-and-words pair. In the Rotunda the words name what the pen will set in motion by Tuesday; in the Rose Garden the words name what the pen has been spared.
"And we should remember that in far too many countries, people like Dr. King never have the opportunity to speak out at all" — the coalition that fought this bill files an Order about proportion, and hears its objection given a dignified form. The family in the front row files a comparison the speech has already refuted four paragraphs above: "Often he was beaten, imprisoned." They part on orientation. This is the one sentence in the remarks that answers an objection, and it answers by moving the standard abroad.
"Thank you, God bless you, and I will sign it" — the House had passed the bill 338 to 90 and the Senate 78 to 22, margins that survive a veto, so the signature was the only move the day left to the signer. The ceremony files a Declaration whose effect is complete in whatever hand holds the pen; the campaign that put the bill on the desk files an announcement, in the first person singular, of an act it produced against this signer's stated opposition. They part on function. Johnson's parallel sentence hands the act away — "the act that you have passed that I will sign today" — and names the Congress in the handing. These four words name no one, and the work the pen could not do had already been done in the six paragraphs before them.